I had Maxliners in my 2019 and decided to go with Tuxmats this time. I was going to go with 3D Maxpiders but it was a tough decision. They fit and look great in my opinion! At one point I was hesitant because of the “bubble jacket” look, but they don’t appear that way in person. They’re also less shiny than I’ve seen in photos, which is a good thing for me.
I wish the transition between the second and third row mattresses could be smoother, but the two-piece design could be a good thing. Maxliners are 1 piece for the 2nd and 3rd rows. I have noticed that it can pile up and end up sticking straight up in the air when people use the third row.